Tricky Hiring Practices: Blacklists

Posted by in Career Advice


There are many tricky hiring practices that employers use to narrow down their list of applicants and some of them can actually make finding a job very difficult. It's important to know what they are in order to prevent or minimize the damage these roadblocks can cause.

 

This week, I wanted to talk about a very tricky hiring process you may not have heard of before. It's called Applicant Blacklisting and although it sounds like something only a few large companies would do, it's becoming more commonplace than you'd think.

 

Basically, blacklisting works sort of like Caller-ID on your phone. If you get too many wrong numbers, telemarketers or other annoying calls from certain numbers, you can block those numbers so that when they call, your phone doesn't even ring. But, what if a series of hang-up calls were being made by someone you care about, who was trying to call you for help and they weren't able to speak? If you blocked the number, you'd never know.

 

The difference between blocking phone numbers and blacklisting applicants is that, for the most part, we don't block numbers all that often. For one, it's difficult to do and many people aren't completely sure how to do it. Secondly, since it takes a bit of effort, a caller would have to meet our “annoyance threshold” before we would take such drastic measures. Finally, just because we block a number from calling our home phone, they aren't automatically blocked from reaching us at other numbers, like our cell phones. However, blacklisting an applicant is easy and there are even companies that reward HR professionals $1 for each applicant they blacklist. What's more, these national blacklist registries are being used by loads of companies, which means that if your name makes it on to a blacklist, your chances at finding a job can be severely decreased.

 

So, what does it take to get on an applicant blacklist? It turns out that it doesn't take very much. Here are some things that can cause an employer to put you on their blacklist:

 

Applying for jobs you're not qualified for – Online job searching makes it easy to send out standard copies of your resume to many different companies. Some job seekers use this tactic thinking that the more jobs they apply for, the more likely it will be that they'll find one. It doesn't work very well and for the most part, it's a waste of time. Employers want to see that the person applying really wants that specific job and isn't just a desperate job seeker looking for any job. If you submit too many resumes that appear to be desperate attempts at finding a job, one of the companies may decide to blacklist you.

 

Applying too many times – When you really want a job, you might be tempted to apply every time you see the job listing. However, if you apply too many times, the HR department might decide to blacklist you.

 

Making a bad impression during an interview – If you really mess up during an interview, say something offensive, come in sick or looking unprofessional, you will probably be blacklisted. However, you don't have to really make a mess of things, sometimes just asking too many questions about compensation and benefits could be enough for a hiring manager to decide that you are just interested in money and blacklist you.

 

Failing a phone screening or skills test – An increasingly large number of companies have begun requiring applicants to take a test to demonstrate their proficiency in specific areas. Sometimes these tests will be a phone screen and other times, they will be actual written tests. If you claim to have specific skills and aren't able to pass the proficiency tests, you might end up on the blacklist.

 

Applying for several different jobs within a company – If you apply for multiple positions within the same company, you can be viewed as being a desperate job seeker. Although it shows determination and enthusiasm, if you don't include a very specific cover letter that addresses why you are applying for a different position, you could end up blacklisted.

 

All of these things are mistakes that are extremely easy to make. People have bad days, mess up interviews and are over-eager during the application process. I know that I've certainly made a bad impression during at least one or two interviews over the course of my career. I've failed a test or two, even though I knew the information. I've been overly aggressive in sending in too many resumes and I've even applied for jobs I didn't think I was qualified for – and that doesn't make me a bad employee. The sad truth is that you don't even have to make one of these mistakes to be blacklisted. An employer can add your name for any reason they'd like and once you're on it, you will have to pay to find out and pay even more to get your name removed.

 

Have you ever been blacklisted? Please share your thoughts about this tricky hiring practice in the comments.

 

Image Source: OpenClipArt

Comment

Become a member to take advantage of more features, like commenting and voting.

  • Jordan Barrett
    Jordan Barrett
    I know I've been blacklisted and I also know its illegal.  It's misdemeanor in a majority of states.
  • Melissa Kennedy
    Melissa Kennedy
    Thanks for all of the great comments. I didn't realize how important this issue was to so many people. I'm not sure how you can find out if you are blacklisted. There are several places online that allow people to pay to have their names removed, but I am not sure if they are scams or not. @Sue, you're right, It ought to be illegal. There is no real benefit to keeping a blacklist, except to extort money from the people who are desperate for a job and who are least able to spare it. It's a horrible practice and the only good thing it does is prevent hiring managers from wasting their time talking to people who (in the worst case) might be annoying or bad workers. @Ellen, starting your own business is a good idea. If you get to the point that you're ready to hire employees, be sure that you are an ethical boss and don't do these sorts of shady practices. @Melissa, it's sad to say that I think you might be right. Somewhere down the line, the "war on poverty" became the "war on the poor," and holding someone down is a common practice. It's shameful.
  • Matthew R
    Matthew R
    How do you find out if you have been blacklisted?  Been looking for work for months.  This organization has an automated application, have applied several times, and have never been called to an interview.  What to do?  Pay to find out?  Who, how much?
  • Jesse B
    Jesse B
    Money used to be a means, but is now used to control.
  • Carolyn H
    Carolyn H
    This is excellent information and know I have been but I do wish someone would have written about this sooner. Thanks this is great!
  • Nora C. M
    Nora C. M
    This is a terrible practice.  I have applied for over 150 jobs in the last year and a half and haven't heard from ANY.  I'm 65.  I have been unable to learn why I'm not called when I've been very qualified for many.  How do I pay to find out if I'm blacklisted and how do I get my name removed?
  • Sue C
    Sue C
    I have been looking for work for over a year.  This is the third time that I have been in this situation.  I applied to every job offered on Craigslist in my field that I felt I would stand a chance at getting and went over half a year without getting called for even one interview.  I feel that I may have been blacklisted, although I have no idea how to prove that.  I have only two more terms left before graduating with my Bachelor's degree.  I feel it is possible that I may have been blacklisted, and I have no money to pay someone to remove my name from a list.  I thought that blacklisting had been made illegal, or at least in the state of California.  Blacklisting should be illegal.
  •  Ellen S
    Ellen S
    I have a chronic illness and a M.S. degree so after years of going down the pot hole filled road, a vocational assessor basically said "your blacklisted".  After applying for over 65 jobs in a rural area to no avail, I moved to start anew.  I will start my own business...
  • Barbara K
    Barbara K
    That is really rotten and unfair. I've been let go from jobs that hired younger employees to take my place. I searched for employment for a year and a half with no success, even exhausted my UI benefits, then had to go into early retirement to afford a place to live. Maybe I was blacklisted.
  • Barbara T
    Barbara T
    I believe blacklisting does exist especially when you've had a terrific interview passed all pre-qualification testing then suddenly after a few days you are no longer in the running. I think some people get blacklisted simply because of their age, weight and ethnicity that doesn't somehow mesh with the interviewer.
  • Kristina J
    Kristina J
    Isn't this also known as discrimination?
  • Bob S
    Bob S
    There ought to be a law against blacklisting.
  • Cynthia B
    Cynthia B
    I think I am blacklisted now. I have not been able to find employment.
  • Julie S
    Julie S
    I don't know if I've been blacklisted however I am beginning to feel like I have been. I have had only 1 call for an interview after 4 months of job searching. I have good qualifications but have not been able to figure out why I am not being called. Then I saw this article and have begun to wonder if this is the case with me. How do I find out if this is in deed the case?
  • Melissa C
    Melissa C
    Americans are getting sicker and more evil as time goes on.
  • Delilah E
    Delilah E
    Way cool! Some extremely valid points! I appreciate you writing this article and the rest of the website is really good.
  • Teresa T
    Teresa T
    How can u find out if your name has been pu n one of these blacklist I am wondering if my name is one there due to the hard time I personally am having getting a job.
  • Melissa Kennedy
    Melissa Kennedy
    @Edward, honestly, I'm not really sure. There are some sites that require you to pay a fee to find out if you're on the list and then pay more to get off of it.
  • Edward C
    Edward C
    How can you get off the list?

Jobs to Watch