Four Common Mistakes that Lead to Job Search Failure

Nancy Anderson
Posted by in Career Advice


In a crowded field, job seekers have a difficult time standing out. Catch the attention of recruiters with a concise cover letter, mistake-free resume and a polished LinkedIn profile. However, some common mistakes can lead to job search failure for even the most qualified applicants.

A 2013 survey of job seekers revealed as many as 75 percent of job applicants did not hear back from an employer. Motivation cannot solve the dilemma of not receiving call backs. Some misguided job search tactics can dissuade potential employers from hiring you. Avoid these mistakes to turn a job search failure into a success.

1. Fill Out an Application and Wait

Sending in your application represents the first step of a job search. However, do not stop there. Find out how to connect to the person responsible for hiring for this position. Send this person a brief LinkedIn message, write him a short email, or call him on the phone to introduce yourself. Lack of action on the applicant's part can often lead to job search failure.

2. Blindly Apply for Jobs

A lack of focus with respect to job searches puts more energy into companies that may not suit your work style. If you find yourself filling out 10 or more applications per day, consider refocusing your efforts. Boilerplating application after application prevents precision with respect to each individual company. Instead of creating accurate, tailored cover letters and resumes, your job search failure becomes an exercise in copy and pasting. Spend your time wisely by connecting with the best companies through LinkedIn and social media, rather than putting so much energy into mass applications. The point of a job search is to get one or two quality interviews rather than to sit around and wait for 20 companies to call.

3. Hand Out Unsolicited Resumes

When you really need a job, do not waste time on jobs that are not there. Waiting for a company you actually want to work for is one of the great, unspoken job search tactics for landing your perfect job. The trick is that you must gradually work up to getting a job offer. Catch the attention of an HR manager or recruiter first before mentioning you want a job and handing out your resume. When you seem too eager and ask about job openings first, you may turn off the person.

4. Frequent Phone Calls

One or two quick phone calls suffice for the initial introduction. However, calling an HR manager every day is unprofessional behavior along the same lines as resume typos and poorly worded cover letters. Imagine if you get several phone calls from the same person while you have 20 more important things on your to-do list. Appearing desperate during the entire process only leads to job search failure. After the interview, two points of contact include a quick thank-you call immediately after your face time followed by a thank-you letter.

Having the passion and energy to go all-out during a job search is not a bad thing. However, many times, job seekers need quality over quantity to avoid a job search failure and to get on board with the right company.


Photo courtesy of photologue_np at Flickr.com

 

Comment

Become a member to take advantage of more features, like commenting and voting.

  • Nancy Anderson
    Nancy Anderson

    I hear the frustration from all of you. But the sad truth is that the job hunting experience has totally changed since the economy tanked. Yes companies use ATS to screen resumes and cover letters. Why? Because for one job posting they will receive thousands of responses. You ask why HR can't go back to doing things the way they used to? How long do you think it would take to go through a thousand resumes for one job? Long time to be sure. That would hold the process up even longer. I am not siding with HR here - just stating facts as I know them. As for them not accepting phone calls, it has been this way for the past 8 years. Again, HR gets inundated with resumes as well as phone calls. They are not trying to be rude or uncaring; they are trying to do their jobs the best way that they can. Taking HR out of the miss would signal disaster. No one would ever get hired! So try to give them a little bit of slack. From our perspective, we should only apply to jobs that we are qualified to do. We should make sure to use the keywords from the posting and incorporate them into our resume. We should make sure that we research the company as much as possible so that we aren't wasting their time and ours by applying for something that we really don't want. It doesn't do anyone any good if we are applying for positions that we are not going to accept in the end because the location is bad or the company's culture is not a good fit. etc. So do your due diligence and keep applying to jobs for which you are qualified. The job market is starting to turn and more hiring is being done. Good luck everyone.

  • CRAIG RIDLEY
    CRAIG RIDLEY

    Unfortunately a lot of truth on both sides of the aisle are being spoken with these comments. Both the HR departments, their processes, their recruiters who at times are not knowledgeable do to lack of experience and candidates who are at times(myself included) think they are "perfect" for the position they are seeking need to find middle ground and understand each others position in the employment process. I have found that offering to be an independent contractor to prove yourself has gotten some attention and worked. It saves the company 20-25% in payroll taxes, benefits etc while allowing the candidate prove his or herself to the company. This approach can work well with start ups.

  • beverly+ s.
    beverly+ s.

    Few agencies accept phone calls these days. I have over 38 years of experience and I KNOW I am more than qualified for positions I apply for. I tried to speak to some people at agencies to discuss positions and their response is if you meet the requirements, we'll call you. They never do. Half of them don't even know the company they represent. Plus don't tell me there is no age discrimination going on.

  • Howard D.
    Howard D.

    Most of the time the secretary answers and say the person you need to speak is very busy. Also, if you sent your information via e-mail and sent a cover letter, they tell you that there are many applicants, so just wait and see.

  • Kim C.
    Kim C.

    Richard I am interested! With so much of the population older and qualified- many are even open to a lesser position but the marketplace seems to be suspect. Great business opportunity

  • Caroline C.
    Caroline C.

    Carl, Anthony, et al., it is just ageism. HR people are likely young and inexperienced and many corporations have not noticed that this can be a problem. I would love to see some case studies investigating salaries, sales, length of employment, age and profit margins so that we can all see the impact of "dumbing down" the workforce with younger or less qualified workers.

  • Jill V.
    Jill V.

    If they don't like you, they don't like you. That;s all.

  • Jill V.
    Jill V.

    You are not going to see the hiring person and you are not going to get an interview. So don't make too many phone

  • ANTHONY LO COCO
    ANTHONY LO COCO

    "dumming" down is a legitimate issue. I like how a HR mgr says 'We feel you are a highly qualified professional, BUT...."

  • Carl B.
    Carl B.

    I'm 50 years old & graduating in mid-June (finally) & going on to graduate school...I'm in transition trying to get to the next professional phase in my life but, it seems like the biggest challenge of my life...trying to relocate & become independent again. I'm interested in PR/Marketing but, all I get are sales jobs inquiries...I'm not interested in sales...very frustrating!

  • Leeann Mosley
    Leeann Mosley

    So sick of being "over qualified" it was actually suggested by someone that I "dumb down" my resume. The problem is that my last job requires a graduate degree so what do I do leave off a good job on my resume and try to answer a gap in employment question just to get an interview?

  • Richard Douglas
    Richard Douglas

    I am thinking about putting together a consulting company composed of only overqualified, older workers. Anyone interested? Sorry -- no on-line resume-builders allowed. Only paper copies.

  • Ralph P.
    Ralph P.

    See David Cole's comment --- that is the problem with HR today -- they think they have some magic that does not need participation by the workers of America. Sorry David but the right candidate with strong credentials is doing YOU a favor by calling -- and I just got a great job by following up on a position perfect for me in just that way. Sur during the process I let them pretend they found me, that they reached out to me, and allowed them to get the "credit" for the "find. I would say better advice is be sure you are a GREAT IDEAL fit --- then call and know you are welcome to call. Check the ego David.

  • Sonja S.
    Sonja S.

    I agree that being over anxious in calling to get a job interview is not a good idea. It is hard not too when you really want to work for an organization but I have to put the restraints on... I too have been turned down more than once due to the overqualified thing... I really wanted a job and it paid about 3 thousand less than I had made before but I was excited about the job and then it went to someone within and will less qualifications ... LIFE!!!

  • Suja K
    Suja K

    Ray P. I totally agree with you. I had same experience with HR recruiters. I had very very bad experience with one of the leading airline industry recruiters. She didn't even know what to ask in the phone screening time after coming into the call 10 minutes late. After few weeks of waiting, I found out that she dropped my resume from the interview pile stating that I don't have the right experience: ) If she was not in that position, at least I would have gotten a face to face interview. I think what is happening is that these open potions are not real. These positions are already filled but they need to post the openings per labor law so they are posting and performing few screening and couple of face to face interview to fulfill the law points. Am I correct in my observation?

  • Samantha H.
    Samantha H.

    Thank you Sue S. I was searching for a way to say what you have put so eloquently. Overqualified means they don't want to pay for our valuable knowledge and experience and would rather take their chances with less experienced individuals whom they can provide less compensation. It is becoming apparent in all of the industries, including HR. That's not to say that a less experienced person shouldn't have opportunities, but it seems that they are selected more and more and the 'overqualified' are skipped over because our skills, experience, and education command more salary than employers want to pay. Just my opinion.

  • Kenny S.
    Kenny S.

    Today
    I've been unemployed for almost a year. Due to a Total Plant Shutdown. I worked there for almost 24 years. Warehouse/Distribution Center. The whole job searching is completely different than 24 years ago. So impersonal. Company's don't reply or say they will call back they don't. It was once said to keep calling that persistent effect defines your eagerness to want a job. But this article make you seem as if you're a psycho stalker lover. With the Internet being so prevalent you are not only competing with locals but people from other cities and locations looking to relocate closer to better paying jobs.

  • Jasvinder B.
    Jasvinder B.

    I share the same frustrating experience with HR screening. I have been unemployed for 6 months and feel that companies should eliminate the Application Tracking System and search words, per say. The applicant can have all the skills, talent and more but if your resume does not pass the keyword count, your resume does not reach the hiring Manager. I condone that HR folks should be phased out and stick to their original job descriptions like administrating payroll,employees and benefits.

  • Michael W.
    Michael W.

    I have been searching for emploent for over 6 months. I have over 20 years of management experience in my field. I find that all too often my phone interviews are with HR personnel who don't have really know what position they are interviewing for. They always promise a real interview but seldom does that ever happen. It is very frustrating. Please HR, know about the position you are screening for.

  • Keith P.
    Keith P.

    The latest HR folks are useless and should be phased out. Most do not know anything about reading resumes, but opt for screening software systems. With all of that free time, I wonder what they do besides bolstering their own ego or trying to get current salary information from prospective employees (I never ever reveal my salary - it's none of their business.) When i finally do hear back from an interviewing company months later, after they have failed to follow up with me after countless rounds of interviews and thank you's, I usually respond with "thanks, but I've already decided against your company due to a lack of professionalism". When you invest 3+ hours interviewing, I expect follow up. If not, it's a signal that it's not the type of company that I'd want to work for.

  • Sharon Faith G.
    Sharon Faith G.

    Totally agree with you, Sue S.

  • Razvan C.
    Razvan C.

    SUE S., I understand your frustration related to not receiving any sort of feedback or follow up from the HR department or hiring manager when they told you, you interviewed well, after you sent a thank you note, etc. It has happened to me multiple times and I think it shows a lack of professionalism on their behalf. There are a lot of positive comments here and the overall consensus is that candidates (overall) are going above and beyond to obtain a job while the HR managers are not showing the same professionalism the candidates deserve.

  • OLUKOLA A.
    OLUKOLA A.

    Why does the company keep telling you to wait more than 6. To 9 months without a job offer made while they keep telling you to hold on!

  • SUE S.
    SUE S.

    Advice such as "following up w/a phone call after your resume submission" is the type of thing that can torpedo your chances in an already overwhelmed employment market. I generally thank the interviewer for their time, while I am standing there as well as mail out a brief thank you note. What IS maddening, is after having what one would consider a very promising interview (the interviewer states they are impressed and very interested), you hear nothing further from the interviewing company. While I understand HR's time is very limited; those who took their time to interview, present themselves in a professional manner and follow up with a thank you note, should stand out. For those of us who are considered "older workers" that have something worthy of notice, to offer to the workforce, it is highly insulting to be told that we are "overqualified" and do not even get an interview. We might well be overqualified but "wasting HR's valuable time" may be one of the best "investments" you ever made for your company. There are many of us out there that are considered "overqualified" but still find it mentally stimulating to have a job to go to daily. We have qualities to contribute to your company that the younger generation will not have, such as loyalty, dependability, manners and grooming. I find it highly insulting to be told to dress professionally for an interview by an HR rep that dresses like they intend to hit the clubs after leaving work. Yes, I realize the younger generation has not the first clue about proper attire but one should practice what they preach.

  • David Cole
    David Cole

    I am in HR. DO NOT CALL to "follow-up" on your submission. Think about what would happen if everyone did that. Candidate management is an art, and the phone calls are not helpful.

Jobs to Watch